Shower Tray vs. Tiled Shower Floor

When designing a bathroom, one of the key decisions you'll face is whether to go with a shower tray or a tiled shower floor. Both options offer distinct advantages and drawbacks, and the right choice depends on your preferences, budget, and the overall design of your bathroom.

To help you make the right decision, read this article until the very end as over the next couple of sections, we’re going to talk about:

• What a shower tray is and the pros and cons of using one
• What a tiled shower floor is and the pros and cons of using one
• The 5 key differences between shower trays and tiled shower floors

And at the end, we’re going to help you make the right decision based on several factors and your personal circumstances.

What Is a Shower Tray?

A shower tray, or shower base, is a prefabricated, waterproof surface designed to catch and drain water from a shower. It comes in various materials such as acrylic, stone resin, or fiberglass, and is typically installed before tiling or other bathroom finishes.

Advantages of Shower Trays

There are many advantages of using shower trays, including:

• Easy Installation: Shower trays are pre-formed, meaning installation is relatively simple and quicker than tiling a whole floor.
• Waterproof: Shower trays are specifically designed to be waterproof, making them an ideal choice for a wet environment.
• Low Maintenance: Due to their non-porous surface, shower trays are easier to clean and require less upkeep compared to tiled floors.

Disadvantages of Shower Trays

• Limited Customisation: While shower trays come in various shapes and sizes, they are not as customisable as tiled floors.
• Surface Damage: Some shower trays, especially acrylic ones, can scratch more easily compared to tiled surfaces.

What Is a Tiled Shower Floor?

A tiled shower floor involves installing individual tiles across the floor area of a shower. Tiles can be made from a variety of materials such as ceramic, porcelain, or natural stone, and the grout between the tiles can be sealed to prevent water penetration.

Advantages of Tiled Shower Floors

• Customisation: Tiled floors allow for more design freedom and can be personalised with a wide range of tile styles, patterns, and colours.
• Durability: With the proper installation and maintenance, tiled floors can last for decades, especially when made from high-quality materials like porcelain.

Disadvantages of Tiled Shower Floors

• Complex Installation: Tiling a shower floor is more labour-intensive and time-consuming, requiring precision and expertise.
• Grout Maintenance: Grout lines between tiles are prone to staining and can require regular cleaning and sealing to prevent mould and mildew buildup.

Key Differences Between Shower Trays and Tiled Shower Floors

Understanding the key differences can help you make an informed decision based on your bathroom’s needs.

Installation Process

• Shower Tray: Generally quicker and easier to install since the tray is pre-formed and requires less preparation.
• Tiled Floor: Requires more time and expertise as each tile must be laid individually and grout must be applied.

Cost Comparison

• Shower Tray: Can be a more cost-effective option, especially for smaller bathrooms. The installation is also less expensive since it takes less time.
• Tiled Floor: While materials like ceramic tiles can be affordable, the cost of labour can add up quickly, especially if high-end tiles are chosen.

Maintenance Requirements

• Shower Tray: Easier to maintain due to its smooth, non-porous surface. It only requires regular cleaning with a mild detergent.
• Tiled Floor: Requires more upkeep, including regular grout cleaning and resealing, to prevent mould or mildew.

Design and Customisation

• Shower Tray: Limited design flexibility compared to tiled floors, though there are many shapes and sizes to choose from.
• Tiled Floor: Highly customisable in terms of tile materials, sizes, colours, and patterns.

Durability and Longevity

• Shower Tray: Durable but may be prone to scratches or cracks, depending on the material.
• Tiled Floor: When properly installed and maintained, tiles can last much longer than a shower tray, with minimal risk of damage over time.

Which One Should You Choose?

Choosing between a shower tray and a tiled shower floor depends on several factors, such as budget, bathroom size, and design preferences.

Factors to Consider

• Budget: If you’re looking for a more affordable option, shower trays generally cost less, both in terms of materials and installation.
• Aesthetic Preferences: Tiled floors offer greater design freedom, especially for those looking for a custom bathroom style.
• Ease of Maintenance: If you prefer a low-maintenance bathroom, shower trays may be a better fit.
• Longevity: For those seeking a long-lasting option, tiles are likely to hold up better over time, provided proper maintenance is done.

Ideal Scenarios for Each Option

• Shower Trays: Ideal for smaller bathrooms, those on a budget, or anyone who wants a quick installation with minimal upkeep.
• Tiled Floors: Best for larger bathrooms or those who want a fully customised, luxurious look with long-term durability.

Final Thoughts

Both shower trays and tiled shower floors have their benefits and drawbacks. Your choice should depend on your priorities, whether that’s installation time, cost, design flexibility, or long-term maintenance.

With that said, if you’re leaning more toward a shower tray for your bathroom, be sure to browse our quality 1700 x 700 shower trays and find the one that best fits your space and style.